My hometown, weirdly enough, had a trove of independent video game stores. The closest GameStop was in a distant mall, whereas I could ride my bike to the local shops. By the time I was old enough to drive myself around, it was easier to buy games online.
The one thing I did at a GameStop was trade up a PS3 model. I forked over the extra to be a temporary "super member" or whatever so I could score mad points from it, but I don't remember what I spent those points on, if anything. Hmm.
I'm pretty pleased that my early day video game consumerist memories are at local shops, though. One of them is still open to this day and I try to visit every time I go back, they're super nice! They're currently a sponsor for an independent wrestling show coming to town.